Sunday, April 20, 2008

An Interview on a Fair Trade Jewelry Model in South Africa

Laurens Mare is CEO of the South African Jewelry Counsel. The interview was conducted by Marc Choyt.

Through the nonprofit organization, Vukani-Ubuntu, you have created a wonderful model that trains economically disadvantaged people from townships into the jewelry trade. Let 's start with what year you were founded and how many people are involved in your program now?

This started in 1999. I joined Demos Takoulas (current CEO) in late 1999. At that stage there was just one project-it was the first project of its kind in the country and the first entity to take gold legally into a township. That was not possible before. We did a lot of ground breaking at that stage. Now, there are 37 structures around including various other projects based on the original Vukani model. Granted there has been some improvements since 1999.

Describe your structure.

We set up a nonprofit organization, funded by government and private companies, that functions to fund as a training facility. This training facility has everything it needs, from machinery to faculty, to bring students into the trade. From this central facility, we have smaller companies that function under it in the hive system. Each of the little factories has access to the equipment from the larger factory, where more technical production elements can be assisted with.

In this environment, the rent of this small start up starts low and then grows as the business increases. He is still linked to the main facility with its expertise, so he can grow his own clientele around himself.

So, if I am understanding correctly, you take people into your training facility, teaching them the trade, while providing them all the support they need?

Yes, and we nurture the businesses until they reach a certain size. Once he has grown to a sustainable level he has to leave the confines of the hive to make space for the next entrepreneur. He still retains the link to the central facility though.

We also have set up a company which sells what is produced in this factory. It is a very cooperative system that has QC in place to make sure that the product creates opportunity to grow business in this method and maintains the supporting infrastructure.

How do you transition them into real life bench experience?

We do an exchange program going into the mass production factory in a mass production environment. They understand the environment and the pressure-this is no ensure that they get first-hand experience of the real manufacturing environment. Training is phase one and phase two is to sub-contract. For example, an order comes in for rings. A jeweler who has completed our program or is working with the program will costs it and send the cleaning and assembly to be done by the developing jewelers as an example.

Who gets to take part in your program?

There is a limited amount of money, but anyone from the townships can apply. They go through test for drawing, hand eye coordination, mathematical skills and language ability. Based on the results, we select our top candidates-ten or twenty out of up to four hundred applicants. But it depends-it can be one out of forty or one out of ten. Unemployment is close to 40% in these townships. One of our trained workers can support 3 to 8 people off his income.

How are the students supported while they are in the program?

Most of the learners receive a stipend as per the SA National regulations through the SETA 's (Sectoral Education & Training Authorities). They provide a list of minimum payments per level reached. In addition, the learners get the opportunity to assist in production and earn an additional income from that.

The more they progress, the more they can produce so their income is finally self-generated.

Can you give me an example of what one of your piece workers makes, compared to the average person in a township?

This very much depends from person to person and which field in the industry they specialize in. As an example a person specializing in cleaning castings can on average earn up to R 4000 per month with someone working for a salary at the same level earning R 1500 - R2 500 per month.

How many small companies have started as a result of your program?

Not that many, I would estimate +- 10 or so that have gone on their own. You must remember that the average period of training for entry level is 3-years. Add to that the additional time spent building up something and we have only really been up and running for 7 years.

What has been your level of success with marketing the product?

That has been the hassle with us, to get sufficient market for the product. But we work with a private company. As mentioned we have set up a hybrid situation, working with established jewelry manufacturers that have viable mass production capacities which utilize us as a resource. Eventually, once a jeweler is solid in his skills, as I said, he breaks away from us and starts his own company. They can still subcontract to the factory. In the process they are learning everything about the business. In the meantime, the money generated goes to development of training and the jeweler.

What have been the challenges?

The problems has been in the operating costs. Keeping the central system functioning, paying the staff running the projects and assisting and training all these guys, to be able to do this, the gas for the car, for example. That is the one place where we are low on funds. Our support network does not want to fund our general administrative expenses.

Please give me a list of what you can produce, and let me know how someone interested in supporting your project might go about working with you.

We will be able to produce just about anything you can find any ware else in the industry. Obviously not the kind of quality you would find in Tiffanies or the like, but reasonable mid range jewelery.

Are You Faking It Or Are You Making It?

Have you heard the phrase fake it until you make it? It 's something which is increasingly common among business owners, especially on the internet or in direct mail. The basic idea is someone sells you a program or course teaching you how they made millions- only they haven't yet made the millions, they hope to do so by selling thousands of copies of the course they sold you. They were lying about being rich to begin with, but if all goes to plan they'll get rich in the end. Odd huh? These tactics are on the rise, so we're going to try and explode some of the myths in this area.

What 's The Point?
What is the point of this kind of business? After all would you take flying lessons from someone who couldn't fly a plane? In one word, the point is laziness! The 'fake it until you make it' guys are typically internet or direct marketers who are possibly new to the whole thing, or just the more experienced kind that are plain lazy. They find a web page or direct mail ad that is very convincing, promising millions of dollars just by following these few simple steps, working just a few hours each day from home. Is there anyone that wouldn't want that lifestyle?

So they part with their money, and are sent a course explaining how to set up a very similar website, selling an almost identical product. They will make money if they can make some sales from this site, the end result hopefully being that they make enough money to take care of the 'make it' part. And then the cycle repeats and repeats, until there are thousands of people selling products, making a few hundred dollars, but claiming to make millions from it on their web pages. A truly strange phenomena, but somewhat of a self fulfilling prophecy.

The Legal Standpoint
Is it legal for advertisers to work on a 'fake it until you make it' basis? I don't know what the FTA would make of it, but I would guess it 's some kind of grey area, as it 's very difficult to prove how much anyone is or isn't earning from their website. Most often they will provide screenshots of proof of earnings etc on the sites that they sell their courses from. They can look pretty convincing, but these days it 's pretty easy to swipe such images from another site, or just create them yourself with Photoshop or some similar program.

Do Any Of Them Make it?
Very few if any. You can make millions from the internet and other direct marketing methods, but it takes consistent effort and skills that are built up over time. If the 'fake it until you make it' guys are too lazy to find their own manner of working and too dishonest to be bothered about telling lies, the chances are most of them are not going to apply the consistent efforts required to learn the ropes or make any money at all. Those new to internet marketing are pretty susceptible to these schemes, and many people do start there before getting their own (better) ideas and becoming successful doing something else.

Is It On The Increase?
Yes, unfortunately so. Modern web technology makes it possible for complete amateurs to create or acquire tremendously impressive websites, sites which can really snare and captivate a viewer. The casual web browser has no way of knowing how old the site is or if the proof of incomes are real or fake or even just stolen from another site. The only remedy is to be extra vigilant.

How To Tell?
It 's very tough to tell if any person is being honest about the claims of their product. Thankfully there are a few tricks we can keep up our sleeve.
Visit whois.net - This site will give you details of any website, the name of the owner, when it was first registered etc etc. Very useful, as it 's unlikely that a website registered 6 weeks ago is making millions for its owner!
Visit Alexa.com - This site keeps traffic stats for virtually every page on the web. A profitable webpage will usually have hundreds or thousands of daily visitors, especially if the site is making the owner millions. It 's very easy to see if this is true by using the graphs here.
Google the site owner 's name. You can find out many useful things with a simple Google search, and if there are bad reports or reports of the site being a scam, you can usually find them with some smart searching.
Look for a guarantee - Many online payment processors, Clickbank.com for example, will have a guarantee, so that if you aren't happy with your purchase you can get an instant refund.

Hopefully you've found this useful. Remember, if you avoid 'faking it' you'll have a better chance of 'making it!'

Interview with Steve D'Esposito on Fair Trade Jewelry

I conducted this interview with Steve D'Esposito:

MC: Given EARTHWORKS' highly charged "Dirty Gold" campaign which many perceived as hostile to the jewelry industry, how it is now that you have now coalesced support to sponsor this jewelry summit? Can you outline, briefly, what led you to this position and the role of the Madison Dialogue?

SD: That 's a misperception. The campaign calls for "No Dirty Gold." It 's not a campaign against gold. It 's a campaign that says we need to add new values to those that society already assigns to the act of buying, giving or owning jewelry.

Let 's take a wedding ring, it 's about adding the values of protecting people, water, mountains, and creatures to those of love, commitment and romance. Therefore, the idea is to make jewelry even more valuable. That 's a winning proposition for everyone and I think that 's why there is interest from all sectors in finding ways to work on some of these issues in a collaborative fashion. This doesn't mean everyone who will participate is in agreement on every issues, it simply means that we agree that it is important to work together, where we can, to help promote ethical, responsible sourcing of jewelry in the small-scale mining sector. Actually, if you look closely at these issues, what 's highly charged isn't the campaign; it 's what happens in communities and to the environment when mining happens without care for people or the environment.

After all, the campaign simply holds up a spotlight and points it at what 's wrong-to create pressure to do things better. The "Madison Dialogue" was set up last year to help foster collaboration across sectors on issues of responsible sourcing in the jewelry sector. Since there were so many emerging projects and initiatives a number of us felt that it would be good create a vehicle that allows us to talk to each other, collaborate and share information. If you go to the website you will also see that the "Madison Dialogue" has also helped publish a number of Issue Papers on key developments in this sector like the work of the Alliance for Responsible Mining (ARM) on the emerging gold standard and the Development Diamond Initiative (DDI).

MC: I would think that such a conference would have TransFair USA (the certification agent for Fair Trade) as a central player. Are they going to be involved at all? Are there going to be any other sponsors besides your organization?

SD: Yes, FLO Internationial/TransFair USA is on the steering committee that has been formed to plan and carry-out the meeting. Other steering committee members include EARTHWORKS, Jewelers of America, the Assocation for Responsible Mining, CASM, Rapaport Group, Ethical Metalsmith, DeBeers, and Partnership Africa Canada. We will also be seeking sponsors to help cover the meeting costs.

MC: What are the objectives of the conference?

SD: This Summit aims to bring together the civil society, community, government and commercial organizations (from mine to retail) that currently are working to address social, human rights and environmental issues in the small-scale mining sectors that supply raw materials (including diamonds, colored gems, gold and other precious metals) to the jewelry industry. It will also include processors and fabricators of recycled materials.
The Summit 's goals are:

* To agree on credible definitions for the descriptive terms that currently are being used to market so-called "ethical" jewelry. These terms include: "fair trade," "green," and other adjectives.

* To recognize credible efforts to develop robust standards and third-party verification systems for ethically sourced minerals.

* To build and/or strengthen partnerships between sometimes-diverse stakeholders interested in ethically sourced minerals, so that responsibly produced jewelry can begin to reach the consumer market in a timely manner.

* To establish next steps both in terms of the development of standards and processes and concrete projects, trials and other activities.

MC: One of the concerns I've had is that up until now, many of the "ethical" initiative in the jewelry industry have been dominated by large players. Yet I have learned from my research that in many cases, with the exception perhaps of the Rapaport Group and Hoover and Strong, the smaller companies are doing the authentic, ground breaking innovative work around ethically sourced jewelry. How are you going to assure, through the organizational structure of the conference, that all people involved, not just the large players, get an equal voice at the table?

SD: You put your finger on a very important issue. My assessment of the sector is that there is, and should be, space for all types of participants looking to advance these issues. I suspect that certain types of activities and projects are a better fit for smaller companies and other types of projects are more suitable at a larger scale. It seems to me that given the small scale of many of the early efforts, the inherently small nature of many ASM projects, and the time it will take to actually bring supply on line, most of these ethical projects are likely to start relatively small and then build. At the meeting we will try to ensure that there is a diversity of participants and an agenda that gives voice and space to all.

MC: Who is invited to come and are there any costs involved for the participants?

SD: Given space constraints there will be a limit on participants-but we will seek participants from all sectors. The steering committee will soon circulate a meeting concept paper that outlines all of this-and there will be a point person for each sector-so that those we are interested and approach the steering committee and request an invitation.

MC: Anything else that you would like to add?

SD: Three things:

1) Your website on Fair Jewelry, is great.

2) It 's important to emphasize that while EARTHWORKS has been a catalyst for this meeting, it 's not our meeting-we are one of the organizers but the meeting will only succeed only if its is owned by all of the participants.

3) We still have one threshold to cross to make sure that the meeting occurs-we need to raise enough money from sponsors to cover the projected expenses and we plan to begin outreach to potential sponsors ASAP.

Interview with Carmen Iezzi

In 2006, Carmen Iezzi, was named executive director of the Fair Trade Federation, which represents more than 250 fair trade businesses in North America.

An Alumni of American University, she knew she had an important and significant job to do. She envisioned her role as the youngest person there; to lead the group with fresh eyes and new energy, working towards an important cause during a key time of growth.

I conducted this interview with her over the telephone and through email:

FJ: Please give me a brief explanation of what your organization does and your position.

Carmen: The Fair Trade Federation (FTF) is an international association of businesses and organizations that are fully committed to fair trade. Since 1994, FTF has been working to educate consumers and vendors and to support our members. I have been the executive director since October 2006.

FJ: Many products designated as fair trade on your FAQ page are not covered by the labeling organization (Transfair USA and the European Fair Labeling Organization). Isn't that kind of confusing? Please explain because, at least on the surface, it seems as if you are at cross purposes.

Carmen: FLO may certify a kilo of coffee beans, sugar cane, or other commodity product, which could then be sold to a conventional or a fair trade company. FTF examines a company 's practices for their full commitment to fair trade. The items listed on our website come from members of FTF.

FJ: There is no agreed upon definition of Fair Trade Jewelry (FTJ), and yet it is listed as a product in your FAQs. There are companies in your organization, such as Global Exchange, that list the Transfair USA logo on their site, suggesting that all their products are third party certified yet they are not. When questioned about their FTJ, they point to your website to give themselves credibility selling FTJ. How am I to make sense of this as a consumer interested in supporting FTJ?

Carmen: Global Exchange sells some certified commodities and is therefore entitled to use the Transfair logo, as I understand Transfair 's policies. Global Exchange is also a member of FTF and entitled to use our logo in relation to their organization.

FJ: What are the criteria for fair trade designation and how these principals might they apply to jewelry?

Carmen: FTF members are fully committed to

- Paying fair wages in local context;
- Supporting participatory workplaces;
- Ensuring environmental sustainability;
- Supplying financial and technical support;
- Respecting cultural identity;
- Offering public accountability;
- Building direct and long-term relationships and,
- Educating consumers.

Carmen in action at the NATO summit in Riga, Latvia

FJ: If it is the businesses that you certify as a member of your federation that if a product is "fair trade" how do you monitor their practices of that business to assure it really is-since Transfair and FLO are not involved?

Carmen: As a reminder, FTF does not certify businesses. We screen an applicant 's business practices and their commitment to fair trade using qualitative and quantitative information and external references. The processes that FLO employs are complementary, but distinct, from our work.

FJ: When I met with a representative of Transfair USA at the FTJ Conference sponsored by the Rapaport Group in Las Vegas last June, there was some concern about any jewelry company using the "fair trade" designation as a means of "green washing." Do you have any opinion about this?

Carmen: Consumers should discourage companies who seek to have a small part of their work offset other, less sustainable practices.

FJ: Is there anything else that you would like to add?

Carmen: Fair trade has a long history in North America and a bright future and items have been available in the United States since 1946 from Ten Thousand Villages and the first fair trade coffee company, Equal Exchange, opened in 1986. FLO was created in 1988; and, TransFairs USA and Canada opened their doors in 1999. The movement seeks to create positive change in the lives of producers by growing fair trade in all product categories.

Is There Such A Thing As Fair Trade Jewelry?

A Google search for "fair trade jewelry" will bring up numerous companies, many of which sell ethnic jewelry produced in small villages in the developing world. The concept draws the socially responsible shopper, yet the third party labeling organization, Fair Labeling Organization (FLO) - of which Transfair USA is a member - does not currently list jewelry. Apart from that, some large players in the mainstream jewelry industry are beginning to tout concepts such as "fair trade diamonds" and "fair trade gold." So how does one make sense of these jewelry claims, especially as they relate to the $150 Billion mainstream jewelry industry?

Investigating the Self-Proclaimed Fair Trade Jewelers

Global Exchange comes up number one on Google in the organic, unpaid listings for the "fair trade" jewelry search. The Transfair logo at the bottom of their website would lead a shopper to believe that their jewelry, like the coffee they sell, is third party certified.

In the context of their claim, I emailed them, asking about the source of their precious metal and the environmental safeguard for their manufacturers - proper ventilation and disposal or toxic chemicals used in the manufacturing of the jewelry they sell. Finally, sterling silver is supposed to be .925% silver. Imports out of small villages in developing countries are notorious for labeling as sterling silver jewelry which has less silver content than real sterling silver.

Global Exchange wrote back explaining that their jewelry is made in a village by small scale artisans and fair working conditions, which they monitor. They could not answer questions about the environmental practices of these small manufacturers and did not monitor sterling content.

This application of the term "fair trade" to jewelry by Global Exchange is backed by a fair trade concept that exists outside of FLO. Global Exchange also referred me to the Fair Trade Federation (FTF), of which they are a member. FTF 's website FAQ pages lists jewelry as a product. I interviewed Carmen Iezzi, the executive director of FTF, which helped me understand that FTF has nothing to do with products: only businesses that sell them-a subtle distinction probably lost on the average person.

Global Exchange, at least, has some history behind their ethical stance; there are many companies and stores using the concepts of "fair" and "eco" around their products with more questionable accountability.

Though "fair trade" jewelry is helping some villagers in the developing world, it is a negligible niche market in the mainstream jewelry industry as a whole, which does over hundred and fifty billion dollars annually.

The Difficulty of Fair Trade in the Main Stream Jewelry Industry

Taking the concept of "fair trade" jewelry out of the village and into the mainstream global jewelry market (think gold, diamonds, bling bling) is like banging that old square peg in a round hole. At present, the industry is totally commodity based and price driven, somewhat like lumber or oil. Fair trade concepts are just not part of the paradigm.

Consider the general conditions required for a fair trade item which is fairly straight forward: coffee. The beans are organically grown often in farms that work collectively, fostering entrepreneurship which translates into broader community prosperity. Third party certification assures a level of integrity that the ethical consumer buying at Whole Foods feels good about.

To translate the same concept into a jewelry product, one would have to factor in labor and environmental practices in the sourcing of precious metal and gemstones. Mining and development of the raw material - metal refining and gemstone cutting - are additional steps. Manufacturing a finished product presents another process with its own labor and environmental issues. Plus, there is a wide range of jewelry products, from toy rings to the high end. Attempting to come to an agreed upon criteria of what is ethical with such an elaborate, disparate supply chain is daunting.

The Ethical Sourcing Movement in the Mainstream Jewelry Industry

Meanwhile, a small segment of passionate, dedicated people in the mainstream jewelry industry are attempting to define "ethical sourcing", with the ultimate aim of some kind of agreed upon criteria leading to true, third party certification. This is going to be a long process. An Ethical Jewelry Summit organized by Earthworks Action is scheduled in Washington DC in late October, 2007.

The jewelry industry derives most of its revenues from diamonds, precious and gemstones and precious metal. The ethical sourcing movement has attracted the interest of governments, large corporations and the World Bank, where the Washington meeting is to take place.

Most raw materials in the jewelry industry are sourced from small scale mining, and efforts are under way to bring ethical practices to this sector. FLO 's early efforts focus on ARM (Association For Responsible Mining). Some companies, such as the Rapaport Group and Columbia Gem House, have taken strong initiatives on their own, extrapolating the fair trade concept to apply to gemstone sourcing. However, precious metals and gems in themselves do not make up an entire piece of jewelry.

Though a finished piece of jewelry could be analogous to a fair trade chocolate bar which may have parts that are independently certified, we cannot have ethically sourced jewelry without addressing manufacturing which has its own labor and environmental concerns. Unlike coffee, mainstream jewelry cannot be easily manufactured in a developing world village because it requires a huge initial investment in equipment and raw materials.

Apart from companies that source their manufactured products from ethical factories, the most notable experiment in this regard is taking place in South Africa in a project called, Vukani-Ubuntu. The project essentially trains people from local townships into the main steam jewelry trade, providing training, mentoring and equipment. It is heavily supported by government and NGOs. But according to Lores Mares, CEO of the South African Jewelry Counsel, one of the most difficult challenges is bringing the product to a market.

Jewelry is strictly a commodity that is heavily cost driven. This ethical sourcing concept does not bring added value because the market is undeveloped. My anecdotal research shows that the progressive, green shopper who buys from Patagonia does not feel at ease with a typical jewelry sales person. Winning the progressive eco demographic back will be easy. Yet those in the mainstream jewelry world who are involved are sincere and heavily driven by humanitarian concerns-with the possible exception of the larger corporations who may be joining to polish their blood diamond, dirty gold image.

Though millions of websites reference "fair trade jewelry," the designation is, at this point, too ambiguous for all but a few main stream jewelry manufacturers to use. The consumer interested in ethically sourced jewelry needs to look for detailed information as to sourcing, labor and environmental practices. At present, transparency is often more valuable to the consumer than any designation.

The Diamond Trade in 2007: How Much Blood Remains?

In March, 2007, I traveled to Turkey, where I attended the Istanbul Jewelry Show. There I met a diamond dealer, the president of a large firm with a large booth. He was the brother of a personal friend and had been in the diamond industry for many years. His primary business was the Russian market, the fabulously rich oligarchy which has a large appetite for bling. The larger, the better.

"How much do conflict diamonds still enter the supply chain?" I asked.

"A huge amount," he said. He didn't trade in these stone, but his customers were not so concerned about the issue. By stating that much of the world diamond market does not care much whether diamonds are from conflict zones or not, he merely confirmed what NGOs such as Global Witness, who broke the conflict diamond story, have said for years.

Blood Diamonds Still Enter the Market

If someone brings a pocket full of uncut diamonds to the back alleys of Mumbai, Antwerp or New York, they will find a way into the supply chain. Amnesty International, states that conflict diamonds are still being widely circulated. No one knows how many thousands of women wear engagement rings purchased some time in the last fifteen years that funded the deaths of 3.7 million Africans. The sourcing of diamonds has too often embodied the opposite of what diamonds represent, when a person falls to his or her knees to propose to their beloved.

The Kimberly Certification Process has definitely affected the trade of blood diamonds. It is an honest and valiant attempt by the international diamond industry to regulate the trade while continuing to have some control of the market, which is in their interest.
However, the Kimberly Process is self enforced, the practices in the diamond industry are highly secretive and there is no system of independent, periodic reviews of signature countries. Diamonds can change hands many times before they reach the jeweler. It is impossible for the sector to close all of the potential holes in the supply chain; from mine to market.

Blood Diamond: Symptoms of Much Greater Issues

Blood diamonds are merely a symptom of much greater issues, though. The current war and destruction in Africa are the result of the colonial policies that destroyed complex cultural structures - the racist, dehumanizing commoditization of people and resources that even now still fatten the economies of the developed world.

For blood diamonds to not exist, we would have to eliminate poverty and injustice in the war torn African countries that are too much in chaos to reap the benefit of this resources. No single government or trade organization can stop this. Love, compassion, fairness and equality would have to be more important than the current relentless greed that drives human misery.

Now, add to the above another issue in the news last year: certification. Last year GIA, was implicated in a grading scandal that rocked the industry. Even a slight variance in grading can mean millions of dollars in a parcel of diamonds. The issues have been resolved and people have lost their jobs and their reputations. Yet recently, when looking to purchase a diamond, an industry insider remarked that certain labs are "softer" in their grading of diamonds than others. This is not the first anecdotal evidence I have heard that has led me to believe that the grading of diamonds is not as objective it is made out to be.

There are extremely wide ranging views on these issues, and many people in the jewelry trade would probably dispute what I write here. Diamonds represent over 50% of the business for the jewelry industry as a whole. For my company, it is less than 10%. I have less to lose in giving my candid insider 's opinion, but it is only an opinion, a snapshot; and I would never pretend to be an authority on this subject.

From the point of view of ethical purchases, the obvious solution for some is to avoid the African supply chain. You can purchase diamonds that are certified from Canada. However, many African countries depend upon legitimate diamond trade, so the ethics of boycotting African diamonds has its drawbacks.

Even Nelson Mandala asked that African diamonds not be boycotted. Ironically, he has become a spoke person for De Beers. De Beers itself has taken on new development initiatives in an attempt to polish their image.

Blood-Free but Still Not Fair Trade

Just because a diamond is from a Kimberly certified source does not mean that it is something that you can feel proud of owning it, as this New York Times article entitled: "Diamonds Move From Blood To Sweat And Tears."

The Kimberly process is regulatory program. It does not address wages or environmental conditions. At present, there are over a million, perhaps as many as 1.3 million diamond diggers. Most of these people are poor. They are often paid under market for their finds. Diamond areas can be as large as a hundred square miles. Even in established mines, as much as 20% the diamond rough may be lost to theft.

The Quest for Fair

The decision of where one should purchase their diamonds can leave the ethical consumer in a "Catch 22." The most worthy viable, ethical solution is to push for ethically sourced, or "fair trade" diamonds now. Already, there are strong industry initiatives to change the way diamonds are mined. One of the most noteworthy is taking place right now in Sierra Leon. However, most diamonds from mines that have strict environmental and fair labor protocols, such as those produced by Wade Watson in Sierra Leon, are mixed in with other diamonds in the diamond cutting centers.

A small group of people, from manufacturers to major players in the diamond industry, have championed ethical jewelry. The "Ethical Jewelry Summit" which took place at the world bank on Oct. 25th, 26, 2007, focused on the plight of small scale, artisan miners in the diamond and precious metal sectors.

Consumers can help too. If just one out of ten of those in search of a diamond engagement ring asked for a "fair trade" diamond, the process would move more quickly. A recent article in the Rapaport Magazine (9/07, published only in print) surveyed sales people in Las Vegas, NV jewelry stores. The article generated some controversy. It found that many who sell diamonds even now, know very little about the conflict diamond issue. These sales people must be besieged by an army of educated consumers who demand ethical diamond sourcing.

The jewelry business, like most every other business, has always shown itself to be more motivated by money than by ethics. However, all of those involved in ethical jewelry practices hope to move our initiatives forward with the support of people in the market who share our humanitarian concerns.

Understanding the World of Tomorrow

Most people do not easily accept the new, mostly because of the unknown factor that people tend to call fear. It is not only as Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoyevsky had put it that "taking a new step, uttering a new world is what people fear most." Even in slight things the experience of the new is rarely without some stirring of foreboding.

In the case of drastic change, like the one information technology has currently imposed on the distribution systems inside every market discussed earlier, the uneasiness is deeper and more lasting. No man is really prepared for that which is wholly new. Everyone has to adjust and every radical adjustment is a crisis in self-esteem. By undergoing through a change people have to prove themselves right. It needs inordinate self-confidence to face drastic change without inner trembling.

In present times, global population is subject to drastic change and has evolved to a population of misfits, unbalanced, explosive and hungry for action. Through action mankind can regain confidence and control, can prove its worth, while at the same time it is actually a reaction against the lost balance. Thus, drastic change is one of the agencies that release a man 's energies, but certain conditions have to be present if the shock of change is to turn people into effective men of action. There must be the abundance of opportunities, and there must be a tradition of self-reliance. This era of technological advancements is probably the most challenging one.

The conditions that prevail today, from the film distribution industry to the ability of people to shop online from Italy while living in Brazil, have created a population subjected to drastic change that it is only a matter of correct timing before plunging into an orgy of action. The issue now is the sacrifices one has to endure in either case. Becoming active and consciously getting involved in any type of action, within any kind of market, the civilized individual has to select a position regarding his/her role in the overall process and sacrifice blissfulness that usually comes from states of ignorance, or apathy.

As Sigmund Freud had written in his book 'Civilization and its Discontents,' civilization imposes such great sacrifices on a man 's aggressiveness that we can understand better why it is hard for him to be happy in that civilization. According to Freud, the civilized man has exchanged a portion of his possibilities of happiness for a portion of security.

Although Freud did not discussed the outcomes of distribution and the severe interference of markets to the circulation process, he successfully conveyed that the stages through which a person undergoes before beginning to feel happy entail usually a scary process of unknown outcomes and difficult to comprehend practices. By trying to avoid the unknown consequences of any major change, people prefer to remain in their constant place with or without any control of their destiny, but holding on to the feeling of security in their familiar environment.

But through network connections and progressive learning practices, this practice has already changed. Future generations will be better equipped to judge the present choices vested upon us. The only thing present generations can do before accepting any change offered, is study and research the reasons behind the negative reactions people tend to have when any kind of distribution advancement is introduced to ease their usual routine. It is always an issue of control and respect of choice.